Puget Sound Best

Northwest Prep Sports

Judge tosses New York parent's lawsuit over basketball player's ejection

State Supreme Court Justice J. Scott Odorisi dismissed the case brought by a Red Creek parent that challenged Section V and state rules over player suspensions after an ejection, saying courts shouldn’t get involved with settling a “sporting squabble.”
“Courts are valuable tools to resolve disputes,” Odorisi wrote in his decision, which was released Thursday, “but they should not be transformed into a Replay Command Center or GameDay Central for every school, or even recreational, sporting squabble.”

Odorisi’s skepticism of the issue was clear during a hearing about this case on June 7, and he hammered home his point Thursday. He said court involvement would be impossible when you consider the number of games played daily around the Rochester area and so many calls by officials that could be questioned